theoretical deficiencies of rural development in iran

نویسندگان

محمدجواد زاهدی

دانشیار گروه علوم اجتماعی، دانشگاه پیام نور غلامرضا غفاری

دانشیار دانشکده علوم اجتماعی، دانشگاه تهران عادل ابراهیمی لویه

استادیار جامعه شناسی مؤسسه آموزش عالی البرز

چکیده

introduction since 1938, a couple of decades before iranian's revelation, attention to villages and rural development as a part of developmental process in national scale and also in order to analyze social, political, and economical changes has been discussed as a vital part and acted a major part in development policies. however, this attention and dedication to the program are results of development literature worldwide evolutions and experiences of other developed countries. in iran, different plans have been implemented for developing rural areas and they have mainly focused on reducing poverty. rural development as an important part of governmental a policies for utterly changing and modifying pervious procedures has held its significance. for this purpose, the government has made its agenda to amend management and traditional structure of agriculture and to establish new organizations and (revolutionary) institutions. need for change and modifying rural structure in order to give a logical form to voluntary institutions which were relying on the young force have therefore been of great consideration. a glance at rural development plans reveals that there are kinds of disorganized thoughts i.e. theoretical problems in rural development planning and so on. moreover, the approaches are varied and with physical and organic positions toward the issue. the main purpose of this research is to explain some theoretical deficits in rural developmental planning in which the ideas of scholars and social experts of the field could be adopted and considered more seriously in these areas. methodology the method of this study is qualitative in which after data- gathering through interviews with (and questionnaires from) scholars and experts, delphi's technique is used to investigate and analyze the findings. the delphi's technique includes the following phases: 1st phase: e- mail and telephone number of 170 individuals knowledgeable and expert in rural development have been collected from universities, associations, governmental organizations, research institutions, engineer counselors and erudite retirees. 2nd phase: by analysis the developmental plans and doing preliminary studies and identifying individuals, totally 13 experts and scholars, extensive interviews have been done. 3rd phase: after extensive interviews and analyzing papers such as all of the papers in the first and second national congregation of rural development in iran, five open-ended questions have been posed and sent by email to 50 individuals who have been active in the rural development. from these correspondents, 15 individuals replied to the questions which move the study to the next level. 4th phase: after posing open-ended questions, 77 multiple questions with five options are posed and sent to 130 individuals from which 65 replied to the questions. after analyzing, questions are divided to 24 categories. 5th phase: finally after analyzing and dividing questions to 24 categories, in this phase 26 multiple questions are posed and sent to 65 individuals who replied in the previous phase. in the end, data derived from questioners are analyzed. results • despite several decades of experience in planning, lack of unanimous understanding in the concepts of development, among planners and decision- makers is obvious. • during last several decades, there has not been any clear understanding about the subject, strategy, and requirements of rural development. • lack of clear understanding about development, has lead to ambiguous and indeterminate goals in development. • lack of professional approach to rural development planning. • although perspectives are changed, methodologies dominate in planning have mainly been quantitative and with pivotal role of planners they acted from top to down. • lack of collective approach toward planning rural development i.e. not participating receivers of plans and reaching to an agreement collectively. • dominance perfectionism in rural development planning. • order-oriented and top-down approaches bin planning development with no expertise's supervision. • dominance of outward attitude toward development. • dispersal and ambiguity of needs in iranian rural societis. • lack of understanding among decision-makers and policy-makers in planning structure of country toward importance of rural development. • mutti-centred management in implementing rural development plans. • local considerations and governmental uncontrolled dominance over issues. • organizations and institutions look at plan as a source of gaining facilities in favor of their own organization. conclusion studying various rural development plans reveals that there is a kind of chaos in ideas, speculations, and theories. iran is in dire need for unified and well-founded theory in this regard, despite its long-term experiences. for this particular reason, long run guide in rural development has not been available. generally, it should be mentioned that elements like dominance of outward approach to development, rigid and quantitative leader based methodology, order –oriented and top-down plans, perfectionism, unclear policies and strategies in rural development, idealism in rural developmental planning, lack of reliance of some decision-makers and policy-makers in planning structure toward importance of rural development, all point out the fact that planning structure has been filled with theoretical deficits cognitively and scientifically. dominant innovative thought along with idealism in theory without any regard for local and inner structure of rural societies in iran, emphasized a conduct and policy which did not produce any fruitful result. furthermore, belief of many policy-makers in new and innovation principles and being indirectly under influence of other requirements of developing countries and international organizations referred to villages as peripheral, as consequence, in planning they are trying to weaken the role of rural areas.

برای دانلود باید عضویت طلایی داشته باشید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

the survey of the virtual higher education in iran and the ways of its development and improvement

این پژوهش با هدف "بررسی وضعیت موجود آموزش عالی مجازی در ایران و راههای توسعه و ارتقای آن " و با روش توصیفی-تحلیلی و پیمایشی صورت پذیرفته است. بررسی اسنادو مدارک موجود در زمینه آموزش مجازی نشان داد تعداد دانشجویان و مقاطع تحصیلی و رشته محل های دوره های الکترونیکی چندان مطلوب نبوده و از نظر کیفی نیز وضعیت شاخص خدمات آموزشی اساتید و وضعیت شبکه اینترنت در محیط آموزش مجازی نامطلوب است.

development of feminist poetics in adrienne rich

اشعار ریچ، به عنوان اشعاری که همیشه در حال تغییر و دگرگونی هستند، تجسمی از رشد و دگرگونیِ انسان هستد. پایان نامه ی حاضر، با تمرکز بر روی مراحل سیر شعری ریچ از تغییری در دنیا به عکس هایی فوری از یک عروس، سپس به شیرجه به درون کشتی شکسته و در نهایت به صبری عجیب مرا تا اینجا آورده، به بررسی این مراحل در قالب نظر شوالتر در رابطه با سه مرحله ی پیشرفت ادبی زنان یعنی مرحله ی زنانه، زن گرا و زن محور می پ...

15 صفحه اول

analyzing patterns of classroom interaction in efl classrooms in iran

با به کار گیری روش گفتما ن شنا سی در تحقیق حا ضر گفتا ر میا ن آموزگا را ن و زبا ن آموزا ن در کلا سهای زبا ن انگلیسی در ایرا ن مورد بررسی قرار گرفت. ا هداف تحقیق عبا رت بودند از: الف) شنا سا ئی سا ختارهای ارتبا ط گفتا ری میا ن معلمین و زبا ن آموزا ن ب) بررسی تا ثیر نقش جنسیت دبیرا ن و زبا ن آموزان بر سا ختا رهای ارتبا ط گفتا ری میا ن آنها پ) مشخص کردن اینکه آ یا آموزگاران غا لب بر این ارتبا ط گف...

the impact of e-readiness on ec success in public sector in iran the impact of e-readiness on ec success in public sector in iran

acknowledge the importance of e-commerce to their countries and to survival of their businesses and in creating and encouraging an atmosphere for the wide adoption and success of e-commerce in the long term. the investment for implementing e-commerce in the public sector is one of the areas which is focused in government‘s action plan for cross-disciplinary it development and e-readiness in go...

The Application of Social Psychology in Iran Rural Development

The concept of development in general and rural development in particular has very wide dimensions. Hence, investigation of these different dimensions requires different views and fields. Social psychology as one of these fields is ignored in rural debates. Social psychology as an applied science could be used in rural studies. Therefore, the aim of this review study was to investigate capacity...

متن کامل

منابع من

با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید


عنوان ژورنال:
پژوهش های روستایی

جلد ۳، شماره ۱۲، صفحات ۷-۳۰

کلمات کلیدی
introduction since 1938 a couple of decades before iranian's revelation attention to villages and rural development as a part of developmental process in national scale and also in order to analyze social political and economical changes has been discussed as a vital part and acted a major part in development policies. however this attention and dedication to the program are results of development literature worldwide evolutions and experiences of other developed countries. in iran different plans have been implemented for developing rural areas and they have mainly focused on reducing poverty. rural development as an important part of governmental a policies for utterly changing and modifying pervious procedures has held its significance. for this purpose the government has made its agenda to amend management and traditional structure of agriculture and to establish new organizations and (revolutionary) institutions. need for change and modifying rural structure in order to give a logical form to voluntary institutions which were relying on the young force have therefore been of great consideration. a glance at rural development plans reveals that there are kinds of disorganized thoughts i.e. theoretical problems in rural development planning and so on. moreover the approaches are varied and with physical and organic positions toward the issue. the main purpose of this research is to explain some theoretical deficits in rural developmental planning in which the ideas of scholars and social experts of the field could be adopted and considered more seriously in these areas. methodology the method of this study is qualitative in which after data gathering through interviews with (and questionnaires from) scholars and experts delphi's technique is used to investigate and analyze the findings. the delphi's technique includes the following phases: 1st phase: e mail and telephone number of 170 individuals knowledgeable and expert in rural development have been collected from universities associations governmental organizations research institutions engineer counselors and erudite retirees. 2nd phase: by analysis the developmental plans and doing preliminary studies and identifying individuals totally 13 experts and scholars extensive interviews have been done. 3rd phase: after extensive interviews and analyzing papers such as all of the papers in the first and second national congregation of rural development in iran five open ended questions have been posed and sent by email to 50 individuals who have been active in the rural development. from these correspondents 15 individuals replied to the questions which move the study to the next level. 4th phase: after posing open ended questions 77 multiple questions with five options are posed and sent to 130 individuals from which 65 replied to the questions. after analyzing questions are divided to 24 categories. 5th phase: finally after analyzing and dividing questions to 24 categories in this phase 26 multiple questions are posed and sent to 65 individuals who replied in the previous phase. in the end data derived from questioners are analyzed. results • despite several decades of experience in planning lack of unanimous understanding in the concepts of development among planners and decision makers is obvious. • during last several decades there has not been any clear understanding about the subject strategy and requirements of rural development. • lack of clear understanding about development has lead to ambiguous and indeterminate goals in development. • lack of professional approach to rural development planning. • although perspectives are changed methodologies dominate in planning have mainly been quantitative and with pivotal role of planners they acted from top to down. • lack of collective approach toward planning rural development i.e. not participating receivers of plans and reaching to an agreement collectively. • dominance perfectionism in rural development planning. • order oriented and top down approaches bin planning development with no expertise's supervision. • dominance of outward attitude toward development. • dispersal and ambiguity of needs in iranian rural societis. • lack of understanding among decision makers and policy makers in planning structure of country toward importance of rural development. • mutti centred management in implementing rural development plans. • local considerations and governmental uncontrolled dominance over issues. • organizations and institutions look at plan as a source of gaining facilities in favor of their own organization. conclusion studying various rural development plans reveals that there is a kind of chaos in ideas speculations and theories. iran is in dire need for unified and well founded theory in this regard despite its long term experiences. for this particular reason long run guide in rural development has not been available. generally it should be mentioned that elements like dominance of outward approach to development rigid and quantitative leader based methodology order –oriented and top down plans perfectionism unclear policies and strategies in rural development idealism in rural developmental planning lack of reliance of some decision makers and policy makers in planning structure toward importance of rural development all point out the fact that planning structure has been filled with theoretical deficits cognitively and scientifically. dominant innovative thought along with idealism in theory without any regard for local and inner structure of rural societies in iran emphasized a conduct and policy which did not produce any fruitful result. furthermore belief of many policy makers in new and innovation principles and being indirectly under influence of other requirements of developing countries and international organizations referred to villages as peripheral as consequence in planning they are trying to weaken the role of rural areas.

میزبانی شده توسط پلتفرم ابری doprax.com

copyright © 2015-2023